What Are Longshot Odds, and Why Do Sharp Bettors Treat Them Differently?

Not every big number on a betting slip means a great opportunity. Here's why longshot-priced props deserve a different level of scrutiny than everything else on the board.

Updated September 2026

What counts as a "longshot"

In American odds, a longshot generally refers to a heavily plus-priced outcome - commonly +300 or longer on game lines, sometimes a bit shorter (around +250) on player props, where markets tend to be less deep. The bigger the plus number, the less likely the market believes that outcome is to happen.

The favorite-longshot bias

This is a well-documented pattern across betting markets, not specific to any one sport: bettors, on average, overvalue longshots and undervalue heavy favorites relative to their true probability. Sportsbooks price partly around real probability and partly around how the public actually bets - and the public tends to be drawn to big-number payouts.

The practical result is that longshot prices are, on average, worse value than their odds suggest, even before accounting for a book's margin. That doesn't mean every longshot is bad - it means the population of longshots skews toward overpriced far more than the population of shorter-priced lines does.

Why this matters for prop research specifically

Player props compound the issue: they're priced off smaller, noisier samples than full-game lines, so a "true" probability estimate for a longshot prop carries more uncertainty to begin with. A model that says a +350 prop is actually fair at +300 is making a much larger, more uncertain claim than a model saying a -120 line is fair at -105.

This is why a lot of edges that appear on paper at longshot prices are noise in the underlying model, not a real market inefficiency - the further out on the tail you go, the more a small estimation error in the model gets amplified into a huge apparent "edge" that isn't actually there.

Why some tools hide longshots by default

Given the above, a research tool that treats every plus-money gap the same as a tight, well-supported edge on a short-priced line will systematically overweight noisy longshot signals. Hiding longshots by default - with the option to reveal them if you specifically want to look - keeps the default view focused on the more statistically reliable part of the market, while still letting you dig further if you understand the added risk.

Toggle longshot odds in the BetIQ app